| NAME | POSITION | SEASONS | COLLEGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pace, Calvin | LB | 2008-2015 | Wake Forest |
| Paci, John | QB | 1996 | Indiana |
| Packer, Mike | QB | 1972 | Lock Haven State |
| Pagel, Derek | DB | 2003-2004 | Iowa |
| Paglieli, Joe | RB | 1960 | Clemson |
| Paige, Tony | RB | 1984-1986 | Virginia Tech |
| Palelei, Lonnie | OT | 1997 | Nevada-Las Vegas |
| Palewicz, Al | LB | 1977 | Miami |
| Palmer, Scott | DT | 1971-1972 | Texas |
| Palmore, Harvey | G | 1970 | Morgan State |
| Pankey, Adam | OT | 2022 | West Virginia |
| Pantale, Chris | TE | 2013-2014 | Boston College |
| Parilli, Babe | QB | 1969-1970 | Kentucky |
| Parker, Artimus | DB | 1977 | Southern California |
| Parker, Lawrence | RB | 1975-1976 | Elizabeth City State |
| Parker, Orlando | WR | 1994 | Troy State |
| Parks, Tommy | P | 2001 | Mississippi State |
| Parks, William | DB | 2021-2022 | Arizona |
| Parmalee, Bernie | RB | 1999-2000 | Ball State |
| Parrish, Bob | DT | 1973-1974 | Duke |
| Parrish, James | OT | 1996 | Temple |
| Pashe, Bill | DB | 1964 | George Washington |
| Paulson, Dainard | DB | 1961-1966 | Oregon State |
| Pawlewicz, Rick | TE/RB | 1976-1977 | William & Mary |
| Payne, Logan | WR | 2011 | Minnesota |
| Peake, Charone | WR | 2016-2018 | Clemson |
| Pellegrini, Joe | DT | 1978-1979 | Idaho |
| Pelligrini, Joseph | OG | 1982-1983 | Harvard |
| Pelon, Claude | DE | 2017 | Southern California |
| Pemberton, Greg | DB | 1975 | Boston University |
| Pennel, Mike | DT | 2017-2018 | Colorado State-Pueblo |
| Pennington, Chad | QB | 2000-2007 | Marshall |
| Perine, Lamical | RB | 2020-2021 | Florida |
| Perreault, Pete | OG | 1964, 1966-1967, 1970 | Boston University |
| Perriman, Breshad | WR | 2020 | Central Florida |
| Peters, Frank | T/C | 1969 | Ohio University |
| Petty, Bryce | QB | 2015-2017 | Baylor |
| Phifer, Roman | LB | 1999-2000 | UCLA |
| Philbin, Gerry | DE | 1964-1972 | Buffalo |
| Phillips, Del'Shawn | LB | 2021 | Illinois |
| Phillips, Kyle | DL | 2019-2021 | Tennessee |
| Piccone, Lou | WR | 1974-1977 | West Liberty State |
| Pickel, Bill | DT | 1991-1994 | Rutgers |
| Pieri, Damon | DB | 1993 | San Diego State |
| Pierre-Louis, Kevin | LB | 2018 | Boston College |
| Pierson, Bill | C/G | 1970 | San Diego State |
| Pillers, Lawrence | DE | 1976-1980 | Alcorn State |
| Pineiro, Eddy | K | 2021 | Florida |
| Pinnock, Jason | DB | 2021 | Pittsburgh |
| Pitoitua, Ropati | DE | 2009-2011 | Washington State |
| Pleasant, Anthony | DE | 1998-1999 | Tennessee State |
| Plumee, Gary | DE | 1965-1966 | New Mexico |
| Plunkett, Sherman | OT | 1963-1968 | Maryland State |
| Pociask, Jason | TE | 2007 | Wisconsin |
| Pool, Brodney | DB | 2010-2011 | Oklahoma |
| Poole, Brian | DB | 2019-2020 | Florida |
| Poole, Steve | LB | 1976-1977 | Tennessee |
| Pope, Daniel | P | 2001 | Alabama |
| Pope, Troymaine | RB | 2016 | Jacksonville State |
| Porter, Bill | RB | 1975 | Midland |
| Porter, Jack | G | 1970 | Oklahoma |
| Porter, Kevin | DB | 1992 | Auburn |
| Poteat, Hank | DB | 2006-2008 | Pittsburgh |
| Pouha, Sione | DT | 2005-2012 | Utah |
| Powell, Art | WR/DB | 1960-1962 | San Jose State |
| Powell, Bilal | RB | 2011-2019 | Lousville |
| Powell, Craig | LB | 1998 | Ohio State |
| Powell, Darnell | RB | 1978 | Tennessee-Chattanooga |
| Powell, Marvin | OT | 1977-1985 | Southern California |
| Powell, Walter | WR | 2014 | Murray State |
| Price, Dennis | DB | 1991-1992 | UCLA |
| Price, Jim | LB | 1963 | Auburn |
| Price, Steve | G | 1975 | Brigham Young |
| Prior, Anthony | DB | 1993-1995 | Washington State |
| Prokop, Joe | P | 1988-1990 | Cal Poly-Pomona |
| Prout, Bob | DB | 1975 | Knox |
| Pryce, Trevor | DE | 2010 | Clemson |
| Pryor, Calvin | DB | 2014-2016 | Louisville |
| Pryor, Terrelle | WR/QB | 2018 | Ohio State |
| Puetz, Garry | OG | 1973-1978 | Valparaiso |
| Purdum, Tanner | LS | 2010-2016 | Baker |
